L&T Archive 1998-2003

surely there must be some merit in it.....
In Response To: Gardiners and Binglers ()

] Whether Jane meant anything by it is pure guesswork.

Consider this:

Smith is not-arguably the most common surname - derived from locksmith, blacksmith, goldsmith, silversmith and whatever other professional -smith there is; there would have been at least one blacksmith in every medieval village, hence the frequency that we find it.

JA gives a person of unknown parentage, ie Harriet, the surname of Smith. She also gives it to Anne Elliot's friend, Mrs Smith. Sir Walter even comments on it,

"A Mrs Smith. A widow Mrs Smith and who was her husband? One of the five thousand Mr Smiths whose names are to be met everywhere"

Then, in P&P, there is a Mrs Long and the Gardiners, both of whom are friends/relatives of the Bennets, whom she must represent significantly in the lower class in contrast to the Darcys and the de-Bourghs. Similar, Mrs Clay keeps in company with the Elliots, and her name gives the same lower connotations. Fairfax is also an "attribute" surname (fair-hair). There is also Mrs Hill, the maid in P&P.

Bennett means "good speaker" . In both Mr Bennet and Mrs Bennet's cases, these are correct! *grin*

Darcy can be derived from "dark" - perhaps, from the dark "bad" light he was shown in at the start.

Ferrars, I think, might come from "farrier", which might suggest that they were also of the new rich - they were not as "upper class" as they would like to think.

However, it had been observed in some other message, quite a while ago, that Fitzwilliam means "son of William", but the fitz-prefix generally tends towards a meaning of illegitimacy - suggesting a blemish to the "higher orders", that JA is wanting to relay.

Of course, all my conjectures could just be delving too much into a lovely story. But it is interesting.

Messages In This Thread

Surname = Previous Profession?
Gardiners and Binglers
I've also wondered
Not a bad idea...
Not necessarily.
Jane's Meticulousness
What's in a name?
Family jokes
surely there must be some merit in it.....
Hmmmmm......
Darcy
D'Arcy?? nfm
Darcy, de Bourgh and Lefroy
Irishness and Poshness
The posh apostrophe
I don't think that you have been misled.....
Darcy or D'Arcy ---Irish origins
Thank you
Darcy or D'arcy Irish Origins
Thank you, very, very much!
Darcys and de Bourghs
Darcy the Viking
The Darcy Pedigree
Interesting!
Right.....
Hugenot
Custance
Custance Connection (long post)
I think....
And a reson for her choice of Bingley & Bennet
Gardeners verus the bingleys
Interesting.....
thanks caroline and heres bingley
FAQ
Oh! And also...
Bingley
Thanks, Caroline
The reason JA chose Gardiner.
wouldn't it be funny...