L&T Archive 1998-2003

The High Price of Sugar...Part Deux...
In Response To: Bouncing ideas...... ()

]] I just found the following information online.

] Can you remember where? ;-)

Luckily, I'd bookmarked it. It was from a Newsweek article - Fall/Winter 1991; title: The High Price of Sugar. I only posted the middle section of the article - the part focusing primarily on Antigua.

About your interesting comments on the above article - I read and agree with most of your conclusions. But while I accept that the life could be awful for slave and slave-owner alike, I'm sure you'll agree that the rewards were not proportionate. Bristol merchant John Pinney lived for twenty years in the West Indies making his plantations as profitable as possible. He left Nevis in 1783 and came home to Bristol worth about £70,000. Similar fortunes were made by many other planters willing to chance the climate and tropical disease.

The same was not true of the slaves. Their only 'reward' was likely to be an early grave. And remember, the Europeans had come to the West Indies by choice, unlike their slave labourers. I find it hard to muster up any pity whatsoever for the plantation owners of the day, I'm afraid, up to and including Sir Thomas.

Messages In This Thread

Mrs. Elton linked to the slave trade?
Rather a friend to the abolition....
I suspect JA of being ironic here
Suckling
Suckling to Hawkins
Not sure.
I read the same paper
Hawkins
Thanks for the link
Well, let's ge the history right, shall we?;-)
Let us indeed get the history right.
Slavery, Tortola, and a primary source....
Awareness of slavery
The dishonourable Arthur Hodge....
Aha!!!
Insubordination in Antigua.....
The High Price of Sugar....Antiguan slave labour....
These things were known at the time
Don't need history books....
Slaves, slave-owners, history, Sir Thomas, the French, outrage...
If it starts from an idea in JA ...
Slaves and other unfortunates...
a quick PS about Uncle Tom's Cabin
Isn't it Uncle Tom's 150th birthday?
Bouncing ideas......
The High Price of Sugar...Part Deux...
back to Sir Thomas
But I'm on your side!
JA, characterisation and further research
Others are following it...
Sir Thomas in Antigua
I am committing one of the seven deadly sins
LOL! If it's any consolation.....
What a fascinating thread...!
Then Let's try some more, and pin it down further.
Some More Thoughts on Sugar and Slaves
Agreed.
Sir Thomas and a different sort of slavery
Thanks Caroline!
At the risk of getting off-topic
British Cane Cutters...??
I think "mud" and "blood"
Let's also get the argument right
Wonderful exchange, but why Antigua, pray ???
Right, Stewart, you can settle it
Why Antigua
Good point!
Australian prejudice
from the land of immigrants...
England sent the best to Oz, of course (nfm)
A well-founded prejudice
Help - they're dragging in the spectators now
Umpires, Stewart, umpires
Yes, but...
British public opinion in 1814
Reactions to history
Reacting
American and other slavery
Patriot Games