L&T Archive 1998-2003

I didn't make myself very clear, I guess.
In Response To: She was no communist ()

I intended what I said as a commentary on her field of vision, not as political or social criticism. Henry Green is an interesting exception among modern writers from the upper classes--two of his best novels are about servants and factory workers: Loving and Living. JA seems to have no curiosity about what working people's lives were like. I would suppose she could have written a good, non-condescending novel about such people had they interested her.

Messages In This Thread

JA and large incomes.
She was no communist
I didn't make myself very clear, I guess.
Re: JA and working class novels
She could...
I was very struck
JA, Servants, and Social Commentary
Plight of the poor but genteel; invisibility of the servant class
I think you are quite correct, Kay.
Maybe, maybe not
Clever Mr. Shepherd.
Clever Indeed
Looking at her narrowness form the opposite end....
I doubt, Caroline,
I've always felt ...
I also forgot Nurse Rooke in Persuasion.
I doubt, Donald
I'm with Katherine on this one...
She was clearly interested