L&T Archive 1998-2003

Dear Aunt Jane
In Response To: Basis for argument..? ()

]f I may quote what another author(Jane Aiken Hodge) says about her: "Jane Austen did her best to conform to the conventions of her day,and after her death the family touched up the picture.She was 'dear aunt Jane'. She played ,supremely well, the part that was expected of her."
] But what did she really think? We are all guessing aren't we.

In hindsight it is always hard to know what another would say. But on several issues Austen remaina a connundrum to me - slavery is one. She didn't seem to approve in full but she wasn't an abolitionist. But if we look to ourselves we can find the same attitudes towards the ills of current society. We don't like them, but ordinary people aren't necessarily kicking up a fuss. (whether that makes me a bad person I can't be sure)

But often in hindsight much of the evaluation may be skewed. I can remember reading an author that was a little disturbed by Austen's teasing Cassandra about a man soon after her fiance died. But I felt that was too judgemental. They were sisters and friends. We have no way of knowing whether Cassandra would have been amused or hurt by the comment. Austen would have been the best judge of that.

And even Jane Austen may be allowed to stick her foot in it. Afterall life is not like a novel where we all say and do the right thing at just the right moment.

But as to Austen being a bit bad - how could she not be? This is the woman who wrote "We met Dr. Hall in such very deep mourning that either his mother, his wife or himself must be dead". She tounge so sharp that one might be tempted to call her "Jane the Impaler". But I suspect her heart was decent enough.

I am not family though - I feel no need to make her a saint. Do we not all want to show our family at its best.

Messages In This Thread

Bad Jane..
Whitewashing JA
One possible cause?
Cassandra and Whitewashing
Actually, Cassandra is innocent of burning Jane's letters...
Thank you, Mary. News indeed1 NFM
Yes, Mary..have you got time for more?
"Time for more" about Caroline and Cassandra...
LOL! Thank you, Mary!
Re: Cassandra not burning letters..
Cassandra and the letters
What's The Problem
The problem is..
Is It, Then?
Oh, Jack!
Point Taken -- Sorry nfm
Basis for argument..?
Dear Aunt Jane
Jane the Impaler
Women are rational creatures
Really? Then you might enjoy...
Lovely Insights
As I said
A Bit Thin
Good or bad ?
What *is* wrong with having servants?
On servants and slaves
Thomas Clarkson
Follow this link
THE industrial town - depicted by Jane
And the town you are referring to is...? nfm
And the Answer Is
The Royal Naval Dockyard, Portsmouth
I take your point, but
Portsea
You got me! Good point. nfm
And another industrial site.....
You can't fool me! It's Lyme, of course. nfm
True, but
Hmm......
St Giles and Seven Dials
British public opinion in 1814
To be fair to the more egalitarian side
Another idea?
Let other pens dwell on guilt and misery
Brought Up To It