L&T Archive 1998-2003

What *is* wrong with having servants?
In Response To: The problem is.. ()


] What I meant to say was that being aware of the stark contrasts in living conditions in society, Jane must have had some thoughts and feelings about it, right?

I agree with Jack Cerf's opinion here, we really have to consider JA is her own time, and not try to impose modern sensibilities. e.g. People on this board often find the class system in JA's time hard to understand, and I am sure that JA would be asking quite a few questions about the social order of today or at the time of the Norman Conquest if she was asked to write a paper on it!

Anyway, I have a point to add, a question really, because none of us will ever know what goes on inside someone else's head - but we are very lucky that we have JA's writings, letters and many other people's insights about her.

What we do know is that JA did appreciate there was inequality in a class society, and wrote about it. Isn't that good enough?

Do you really believe that JA really appreciated our so-
called inequalities in her society? i.e. servants, slavery etc. Is there any evidence that JA ever went to an industrial town, a coal mine or factory and saw the *real* inequalities there? She lived all her live in pleasant places in the South of England. Did she ever go to a plantation and see slavery first hand? Did she ever meet anyone who could have given her some anti-slavery information? Of course she knew about servants, but servants were actually well off - they had room, board and wages, and mostly looked after well by their employers. People work for other people today - I do very long hours for my employer in my office job for a few pounds so I can live.

Messages In This Thread

Bad Jane..
Whitewashing JA
One possible cause?
Cassandra and Whitewashing
Actually, Cassandra is innocent of burning Jane's letters...
Thank you, Mary. News indeed1 NFM
Yes, Mary..have you got time for more?
"Time for more" about Caroline and Cassandra...
LOL! Thank you, Mary!
Re: Cassandra not burning letters..
Cassandra and the letters
What's The Problem
The problem is..
Is It, Then?
Oh, Jack!
Point Taken -- Sorry nfm
Basis for argument..?
Dear Aunt Jane
Jane the Impaler
Women are rational creatures
Really? Then you might enjoy...
Lovely Insights
As I said
A Bit Thin
Good or bad ?
What *is* wrong with having servants?
On servants and slaves
Thomas Clarkson
Follow this link
THE industrial town - depicted by Jane
And the town you are referring to is...? nfm
And the Answer Is
The Royal Naval Dockyard, Portsmouth
I take your point, but
Portsea
You got me! Good point. nfm
And another industrial site.....
You can't fool me! It's Lyme, of course. nfm
True, but
Hmm......
St Giles and Seven Dials
British public opinion in 1814
To be fair to the more egalitarian side
Another idea?
Let other pens dwell on guilt and misery
Brought Up To It